All episodes
Book Club Fact File: Tragedy at Law by Cyril Hare (No Spoilers)
The Art of the Cluefinder
Dear listeners, Are you the kind of reader who likes to solve the mystery as you read, racing the detective to the solution, or do you prefer to spectate and allow the author to lay out the resolution for you? Personally, I flip between these two styles: there are some
The Cluefinder
A literary device from the golden age of detective fiction is making a comeback.
The Cluefinder Transcript
Caroline: The classic murder mystery is full of tropes. You will be familiar with lots of them: the closed circle of suspects, the automatic suspicion of the least likely perpetrator, the impossible crime, the locked room mystery, the final chapter reveal, the last minute twist. In addition to these, a
The Cluefinder (Ad Free)
Audiobook: The Fenchurch Street Mystery by Baroness Orczy
Reading Recommendations: Lighthouse, Penhallow, Mice, Fate
Dear listeners, Summer holidays are coming to an end at Shedunnit HQ and I'm excited about the planning I've been doing for the next few months of podcasting. I think there are some good episodes coming up between now and the end of the year. Meanwhile,
Rediscovering Miss Marple
Reading Agatha Christie like it's 1930.
Rediscovering Miss Marple
Getting back in touch with the foremost citizen of St Mary Mead.
Rediscovering Miss Marple Transcript
Caroline: Some characters are so popular and recognisable that they can become detached from their point of origin. Miss Marple is such a one. There were elderly women sleuths before her, but every single village busybody who solves crimes since has existed in her shadow. Her stories and novels are
Bonus: Hotline Extras II
We're All Going On A Summer Holiday
A trip into the Shedunnit archive.
Book Club Fact File: The Cellars of the Majestic by Georges Simenon (No Spoilers)
Book Club Conversation: The Cellars of the Majestic by Georges Simenon (Full Spoilers)
Murder at the Bookshop
Here are some bibliomysteries that you might want to try.
Murder at the Bookshop
Death lurks among the shelves — in crime fiction, that is.
Murder at the Bookshop Transcript
Caroline: Certain jobs and pastimes come with a higher degree of risk. This we know. I hope that everyone who decides to become a racing driver, or climb a mountain without ropes, or chase tornados, understands that their chosen activity comes with a heightened chance of injury or death. What
Murder at the Bookshop (Ad Free)
Audiobook: A Mystery of the Sand-Hills by R Austin Freeman
Reading Recommendations: Paretsky, MacDonald, Lee, Mead
Dear listeners, The month of July has flown by and it's time for another book recommendation newsletter, in which I and Shedunnit production assistant Leandra offer you a peek into our personal reading experience while we are working on the podcast. You can catch up with the last
Investigating a Death on Paper
Dear listener, For today's new episode, I am venturing into the world of epistolary crime novels. This is the kind of mystery where the story is told through a series of letters or documents rather than a continuous prose narrative. There is a strong tradition of this format
Death on Paper
There’s a lot of fun to be had with an epistolary mystery.
Death On Paper Transcript
Caroline: Dear listener, I trust this letter finds you well. Perhaps you are curled up somewhere cosy, pressing play as a break from reading your favourite detective novel. Or maybe you are out and about, using the podcast to stay connected to the golden age of detective fiction even while
Death on Paper (Ad Free)
July Update from the Shedunnit Book Club
What we're doing and reading this month.
Three Books That Live On My Desk
The reference works that make Shedunnit possible.
Book Club Conversation: The Feast by Margaret Kennedy (Full Spoilers)
Book Club Fact File: The Feast by Margaret Kennedy (No Spoilers)
The Man in the Dark
A closer look at John Ferguson's foggy 1928 "Ealing mystery".
The Man in the Dark (Green Penguin Book Club 10)
Golden age expert Kate Jackson joins Caroline to read John Ferguson’s intriguing “Ealing mystery”.
The Man in the Dark Transcript (Green Penguin Book Club 10)
Green Penguin Music Caroline: Welcome to Shedunnit. I’m Caroline Crampton. And welcome back to Green Penguin Book Club, a series within Shedunnit that documents my journey of reading and discussing every crime or green title from the main Penguin series, in order. Our book today is The Man in
The Man in the Dark (Green Penguin Book Club 10, Ad Free)
Reading Recommendations: Ferguson, Kennedy, Rinehart, Osler
Dear listeners, It's time for another monthly book recommendation newsletter, in which I and Shedunnit production assistant Leandra offer you a peek of our personal reading experience. There was some excellent chat in the comments of last month's edition, so if you have suggestions for what
Audiobook: The Murder on the Golf Links by M McDonnell Bodkin
Inside The Poison Book
Dear friends, It was last autumn, when I was rereading Agatha Christie's The Mysterious Affair at Styles for the Green Penguin Book Club episode on that book, that I began to wonder what the point of the "poison book" really was. I'm sure you
The Poison Book Transcript
Caroline: "Poison book" or "poison register" is a phrase that crops up quite a bit in golden age detective fiction. I'm sure lots of you have come across it in this fictional context, where a character is asked to sign such a volume so
The Poison Book
How crime writers turned pharmaceutical regulations into plot points. Apple Podcasts | Spotify | BBC Sounds | Other apps | RSS | Transcript My guest for this episode is Dr Kathryn Harkup. Her book V is for Venom: Agatha Christie’s Chemicals of Death is available now. Support the podcast by joining the Shedunnit Book
The Poison Book (Ad Free)
Sherlock and Shedunnit
A trip into the Shedunnit archive.
Book Club Fact File: Lady Molly of Scotland Yard by Baroness Orczy (No Spoilers)
Book Club Conversation: Lady Molly of Scotland Yard by Baroness Orczy (Full Spoilers)
The Murder Mystery Hotline Is Open
Lighthouses, chocolate, harps, China and more.
The Murder Mystery Hotline II
Our golden age detective fiction recommendation line is at your service. Apple Podcasts | Spotify | BBC Sounds | Other apps | RSS | Transcript Support the podcast by joining the Shedunnit Book Club and get extra Shedunnit episodes every month plus access to the monthly reading discussions and community: shedunnitbookclub.com/join. Books mentioned
The Murder Mystery Hotline II Transcript
Caroline: Over the almost seven years that I have been making Shedunnit, I have seen over and over again that a really considered and specific book recommendation can be a way of demonstrating care and affection. So many of the lists and suggestions that appear out there in the wider
The Murder Mystery Hotline II (Ad Free)
Reading Recommendations: Rolls, Ferguson, Cadfael, Rinehart
Dear listeners, We're back with another monthly book recommendation newsletter, sharing what I and Shedunnit production assistant Leandra have been spending our reading time on recently. I really enjoyed chatting to some of you in the comments last time and got some good ideas there for future reads,
Audiobook: An Intangible Clue by Anna Katharine Green
An Inspector Calls
It's a detective showdown: amateur vs professional.
An Inspector Calls Transcript
The stock detective of golden age detective fiction is definitely an amateur. It's someone at the country house party who has the role of sleuth thrust upon them by circumstance, or a person with known criminological interests who has built up a reputation for repeatedly solving crimes simply
An Inspector Calls
Because sometimes, only a professional will do. Apple Podcasts | Spotify | BBC Sounds | Other apps | RSS | Transcript Support the podcast by joining the Shedunnit Book Club and get extra Shedunnit episodes every month plus access to the monthly reading discussions and community: shedunnitbookclub.com/join. Books mentioned in this episode: — The
An Inspector Calls (Ad Free)
The Four Just Men (Green Penguin Book Club 9)
Locked room mystery specialist Tom Mead joins Caroline to read Edgar Wallace’s sensational 1905 thriller. Apple Podcasts | Spotify | BBC Sounds | Other apps | RSS | Transcript No major plot spoilers until you hear Caroline say we are "entering the spoiler zone", at 20:56. After that, expect full spoilers.
The Four Just Men Transcript (Green Penguin Book Club 9)
Green Penguin Music Caroline: Welcome to Shedunnit. I’m Caroline Crampton. And welcome back to Green Penguin Book Club, a series within Shedunnit that documents my journey of reading and discussing every crime or green title from the main Penguin series, in order. Our book today is The Four Just
Book Club Fact File: Murder by Matchlight by ECR Lorac (No Spoilers)
Book Club Conversation: Murder by Matchlight by ECR Lorac (Full Spoilers)
The Four Just Men (Green Penguin Book Club 9, Ad Free)
A Visit to Josephine Tey's Inverness
Dear listeners, At the very start of the year, when the weather was an awful lot colder than it is now, I got to pay a visit to the birthplace and longtime home of Josephine Tey: Inverness. My husband Guy and I, along with Morris the dog, were on the
Reading Recommendations: Wallace, Heyer, Jackson Bennet, Allingham
Dear listeners, Shedunnit has joyfully shaken the dust of social media from its shoes — I truly do not miss it at all — but I still want to have a place for sharing and discussing reading recommendations with you all. And so from now on, on the first Monday of each
Audiobook: The Perfect Plan by James Hilton
The Crimes of Dorothy Erskine Muir
Dear listeners, One of the best things about making Shedunnit is getting to introduce people to lesser-known books and writers that I think are really good. And that's what today's new episode and newsletter are all about: bringing the life and work of Dorothy Erskine Muir
The Crimes of Dorothy Erskine Muir Transcript
Caroline: Reading crime fiction is about curiosity and the desire for knowledge. We start each book with no idea what has happened in the story's pivotal scenario and, at least in the certainty-orientated golden age tradition from the interwar years, by the end we will know all about
The Crimes of Dorothy Erskine Muir
Fact meets fiction in the work of this unjustly overlooked writer. Apple Podcasts | Spotify | BBC Sounds | Other apps | RSS | Transcript Moonstone Press are very kindly running a special offer for the 30 days after this episode airs: if you buy the paperback set of Erskine Muir's three novels,
The Crimes of Dorothy Erskine Muir (Ad Free)
Taking A Closer Look At Ngaio Marsh
A little trip into the Shedunnit archive.
Which Is The Best Christianna Brand Novel?
Dear listeners, Christianna Brand is an author that I had long admired from afar. I had loved the 1946 film adaptation of Green for Danger starring Alastair Sim for years before I even read the novel, and other than a couple of her other titles that had been chosen as
Ranking Christianna Brand Transcript
Caroline: One of the great pleasures of golden age detective fiction, I think, is that some of its best writers were very prolific. It makes it easy to fall down a bibliography shaped rabbit hole. You liked your first Agatha Christie? Don't worry, there are at least sixty
Ranking Christianna Brand
Caroline dives deep into Brand’s work to find her favourite novel. Apple Podcasts | Spotify | BBC Sounds | Other apps | RSS | Transcript Back in July of last year, I did an episode titled Christianna Brand's Impossible Crimes. During the research and preparation for that episode, I read quite a
Bonus: Ask Me Anything 2025
Book Club Fact File: The Murder at the Vicarage by Agatha Christie (No Spoilers)
Book Club Conversation: The Murder at the Vicarage by Agatha Christie (Full Spoilers)
Is It A Perfect Crime By 1931 Standards?
Let's see what's in the Green Penguin postbag.
Raffles Transcript (Green Penguin Book Club 8)
Green Penguin Music Caroline: Welcome to Shedunnit. I’m Caroline Crampton. And welcome back to Green Penguin Book Club, a series within Shedunnit that documents my journey of reading and discussing every crime or green title from the main Penguin series, in order. Our book today is Raffles by E.
Raffles (Green Penguin Book Club 8)
Darryl Jones joins Caroline to discuss the first collection of Raffles stories. Apple Podcasts | Spotify | BBC Sounds | Other apps | RSS | Transcript No major plot spoilers until you hear Caroline say we are "entering the spoiler zone", at 10:30. After that, expect full spoilers. A full list of
Audiobook: The Clever Mrs Straithwaite by Ernest Bramah
Raffles (Green Penguin Book Club 8, Ad Free)
Oxford vs Cambridge
Why do these two historic university cities appear in so many murder mysteries? Apple Podcasts | Spotify | BBC Sounds | Other apps | RSS | Transcript Books mentioned in this episode: — The Masters by C.P. Snow — Lucky Jim by Kingsley Amis — Brideshead Revisited by Evelyn Waugh — Zuleika Dobson by Max Beerbohm — Gaudy Night
Oxford vs Cambridge Transcript
Caroline: The precise appeal of golden age detective fiction is a tricky equation to solve, I find. These are books about violence and murder that we read for pleasure and relaxation. They tend to focus on a very narrow slice of society, the wealthy, and work with a small set
Oxford vs Cambridge (Ad Free)
Book Club Conversation: Last Bus to Woodstock by Colin Dexter (Full Spoilers)
Book Club Fact File: Last Bus to Woodstock by Colin Dexter (No Spoilers)
The Mystery Short Story
A consideration of crime fiction’s more compact incarnation. Apple Podcasts | Spotify | BBC Sounds | Other apps | RSS | Transcript Please be aware that there are spoilers in this episode for the two stories discussed here in detail: "Traitor's Hands" by Agatha Christie and "A Jury of
The Mystery Short Story Transcript
Leandra: In March of 1927, The Strand Magazine introduced a competition for its readers. Sir Arthur Conan Doyle would select his twelve favourite Sherlock Holmes short stories, and the fan who guessed the author’s list “most nearly” would win £100 and an autographed copy of his book, Memories and
The Mystery Short Story (Ad Free)
Audiobook: The Well by W.W. Jacobs
Agatha Christie’s Taste in Crime Fiction Transcript
She is beloved worldwide for her crime writing. But what did she like to read?
Agatha Christie's Taste in Crime Fiction
She is beloved worldwide for her crime writing. But what did she like to read?
Agatha Christie’s Taste in Crime Fiction (Ad Free)
Book Club Fact File: The Conjure-Man Dies by Rudolph Fisher (No Spoilers)
Book Club Conversation: The Conjure-Man Dies by Rudolph Fisher (Full Spoilers)
The Missing Moneylender by W. Stanley Sykes Transcript (Green Penguin Book Club 7)
Green Penguin Music Caroline: Welcome to Shedunnit. I’m Caroline Crampton. And welcome back to Green Penguin Book Club, a series within Shedunnit that documents my journey of reading and discussing every crime or green title from the main Penguin series, in order. Our book today is one I'
The Missing Moneylender by W. Stanley Sykes (Green Penguin Book Club 7)
Moira Redmond joins Caroline to consider a surprising medical mystery from 1931. No major plot spoilers until you hear Caroline say we are "entering the spoiler zone", at 19:39. After that, expect full spoilers. A full list of titles in the Penguin series can be found at
The Missing Moneylender by W. Stanley Sykes (Green Penguin Book Club 7, Ad Free)
Audiobook: Mystery of the Slip Coach by Sapper
On Gaudy Night
Caroline goes deep on Dorothy L. Sayers’ 1935 masterpiece. At 18:58, there is a brief mention of attempted suicide. Books mentioned in this episode: — Gaudy Night by Dorothy L Sayers — Whose Body? by Dorothy L Sayers — Strong Poison by Dorothy L Sayers — Have His Carcase by Dorothy L Sayers
On Gaudy Night Transcript
Caroline: J.R.R. Tolkien couldn't stand it. George Orwell thought it was a bad detective story. One critic has described its protagonist as "a Yoko Ono figure" who lured her creator away from writing crime fiction. And yet, Gaudy Night is a brilliant and beloved
Bonus: Caroline Ranks Edmund Crispin's Novels
Book Club Fact File: The Paddington Mystery by John Rhode (No Spoilers)
Book Club Conversation: The Paddington Mystery by John Rhode (Full Spoilers)
Whodunnit Centenary: 1925
Reading the mysteries of the past 100 years. Books mentioned in this episode: — 1925: The Paddington Mystery by John Rhode — The Secret of Chimneys by Agatha Christie — 1935: Gaudy Night by Dorothy L Sayers — The Omnibus of Crime: Great Short Stories of Detection — The Murder of Roger Ackroyd by Agatha